Britain’s Got Talent - Week 3
April 27, 2009
If you think Susan Boyle mania is out of control in Britain, you should try being in America, as I am at the moment.
Every TV show, magazine, newspaper, and radio station is absolutely obsessed with her, and it’s no exaggeration to say that right now, Susan is the hottest star in the U.S.
When you think that the likes of poor old Robbie Williams and Jonathan Ross have been trying for 15 years to crack it here, and she’s done it in just a week, this does seem a little unfair. But hey, that’s showbiz.
I did 50 TV interviews yesterday, right across the country, supposedly to promote the new series of America’s Got Talent, and all any of them cared about was when I’m having my hot date with Susan, what did I think of her ‘makeover’, and can anyone beat her in Britain’s Got Talent.
(The answers, by the way, are 1) As soon as I get back 2) Is there any woman in the world who wouldn’t have a new haircut if she knew 100 million people were watching her on the internet? And 3) It’s going to be thrilling watching them try.)
The Boyle phenomenon has got so insane, I’ve got a horrible feeling that when I die, the headlines are now going to read: ‘JUDGE IN SUSAN BOYLE VIDEO DIES.’
As for Saturday’s show, I watched it on my laptop on the balcony of my Hollywood hotel (you can see the sign from my room and it never fails to remind what a jammy little devil I am…) and I howled with laughter all the way through.
Simon often says that he thinks BGT has replaced traditional comedy shows on TV, and he’s right. It’s hilarious to judge, and hilarious to watch back the superbly produced edited highlights.
Show 3 had it all, from the wonderfully deluded opening singer Claire, to the magnificently barmy DJ Talent, and the world’s worst drag act, Tia Anna.
But who am I to mock others when I made such a spectacular fool of myself with that big wheel, nearly killed that poor bloke during his arm-standing knife act, and danced so badly that Kelly Brook had to beg me to stop?
Incidentally, I hope all those who’ve sneered at Kelly when she left the show after just a few days have now eaten their words. I thought she was warm, pretty and fun. It was never about her, it was about the problems a 4th judge brought to the mechanics of the show.
Though for me, there can only ever be one hot totty on BGT - the gorgeous Amanda will always get my vote.
As for the talent, Diversity were brilliant. But Hollie, the pint-sized little ballerina with the amazing voice, eclipsed even them with her stunning routine.
Can anyone beat Susan Boyle?
Yep, I think Hollie can. And so can Shaheen from last week. And so can a few other acts you haven’t even seen yet. It will all depend on how they do in the live semi-finals. Assuming they all make the final Top 40 cut obviously (prepare for a few big shocks on that score, by the way)!
One thing’s for sure - boy, do we have a competition now…
Want more BGT? Check in with the hosts Ant & Dec’s Blog here.
April 27, 2009 at 11:40 am
Sherry says
Dear Piers,
If you haven’t already seen the clip of Susan Boyle’s audition in 1995 for the Michael Barrymore show, please look at it on the Scottish newspaper
dailyrecord.co.uk.
To watch how disgustingly he treated her and how she kept on singing beautifully is heart-rending. Any woman watching this clip will cringe at Susan’s treatment by this sexist pig.
Surely after all that Susan has been through and how miserably she has been treated over many years, she truly deserves beautiful things to happen to her now. Here’s hoping that everyone will treat her with the respect she deserves and ensure that she has the career she has always wanted and merits.
Sherry
Jacksonville, Florida USA
April 27, 2009 at 12:56 pm
Digital Mischief says
Susan is about heart and talent - maybe some of us see a little bit of ourselves in her. She was willing to take a risk at later age that counts as much as her lovely voice. She’s our Cinderella! We all make adjustments in our appearance to fit our personal needs, so you go gal - we’re behind you!
Piers, thanks to the ‘Susan Adventure’ I discover you and your blogs and extra plusl
Patrish
Sarasota, FL, USA
April 27, 2009 at 2:30 pm
Kris Drum says
To Sherry, I watched that video clip of Susan Boyle and that ignoramous prat MB - call it Karma but Susan will most definately have the last laugh.
If you go onto Wikipedia you will read for yourself just how low MB sunk.
Being a fellow Scot I think Susan is absolutely terrific.
You better hurry back Piers for that dinner date with the most famous woman on the planet right now!
Go Susan go!
April 27, 2009 at 3:47 pm
scott says
sounds exciting kelly was HOT !!!!
April 27, 2009 at 4:31 pm
Ammie says
I just read that if Susan wins BGT then Simon will put her on America’s Got Talent. That’s crazy talk. It’s time for Susan to move on to bigger and better things. Why would she subject herself to another contest? I hope this is just tabloid fodder.
I think many of the fans, including myself, feel protective of Susan.
April 27, 2009 at 5:03 pm
Barbara says
I dont thinnk it is to compete, just guess appearance I believe.
April 27, 2009 at 5:18 pm
Emily says
I think it’s great that Susan Boyle’s such a huge hit there in Britain and here in the United States. Aside from the fact that she’s just fabulous, if her video hadn’t moved so quickly over the internet, I might never have discovered the awesomeness that is Britain’s Got Talent.
Definitely a hilarious show…and I love seeing the varied talent. I thought Diversity was just GREAT.
April 27, 2009 at 10:48 pm
Susy says
Sherry, just sawa the video of that audition….guess she has been kissed before!
April 28, 2009 at 12:06 am
Deb in Canada says
She has got about 6 billions big brothers and sisters keeping an eye on her right now. let her ride the crest, compete in the finals and hopefully win. After that she has can live her dream. (I am sure if she doesn’t come in first, she will still get a huge record deal, look at the American Idol contestants who came in second or third
)
She looks wonderful and heck, if millions of people were watching my every move and dredging up old vids of me, I’d dash off to the stylist to get my hair freshen up and have my brows fixed a bit. heck, give the poor woman a break.
This must be so over whelming for her. I hope they have super security and media advisers for her. There are some not so nice people out there unfortunately.
You go Susan! We are all behind you…the whole world loves you and wants you to win!
April 28, 2009 at 12:30 am
Kim says
I don’t see the problem with Susan Boyle showing up on America’s Got Talent. I think they should have a World’s Got Talent contest where all of the finalists from each country get together to compete - that would be fun! It would also allow people from each country to get more exposure than their individual countries. Just an idea….
I also feel very protective of Susan. I hope her brothers pushing her one way, journalists this way, and the pressure do not get to her. We see so many stars that have trouble handling their fame. I think her brothers should knock it off. She will still have her fan base a few weeks from now. We are not going anywhere!
Piers - I learned about you from the Susan Boyle video, but I have enjoyed watching you on both BGT clips on YouTube and when you dropped in on Celebrity Apprentice recently — Good luck to you and Susan, too.
April 28, 2009 at 2:10 am
Mary Jo says
This is not advice; I’m not qualified to give it. It is my opinion as a potential record buyer. Simon Cowell will get more of my money ( & that of a lot of other Americans) if he negotiates Susan’s release from the show in exchange for a piece of the proceeds from live performances & albums in the USA for a given period of time–say 2 years.
Otherwise there will be a stalemate like the one between YouTube & ITV over who gets to control this phenomenom, & millions of dollars & pounds will be lost. We Americans are sitting around twiddling our thumbs until we can hear her sing again, and have something to listen to without having to log on. Since we don’t have a vote on the show, it doesn’t matter to us whether she wins or not. It also isn’t fair to the other contestants. They should have a chance to compete without swimming against this planet-wide tide.
I was a teenager when the Beatles were just becoming popular in the 50’s, & they were considered just another flash-in-the-pan kid band at first. Not only their popularity, but also the quality of their music, continued to grow. I think the same thing can happen with Ms. Boyle, but not if Mr. Cowell continues to try forcing her into the aspiring contestant mold, instead of giving her the room to develop her popularity and her abilities beyond the narrow confines of a talent show.
I hope Mr. Cowell lets her spread her wings NOW outside the show, while giving her some business guidance, & taking a share of the profits she’ll generate, and give a chance to the remaining contestants. That’s what this USA fan would like to see, anyway.
April 28, 2009 at 5:18 am
Julie says
I for one hopes Susan Boyle wins. Personally I get sick and tired of the pip squeaks on both the American and British Versions. Taking the lime light away from real adult talent. If a 30 something Sarah Brightman type person came along it wouldn’t be as annoying.
April 28, 2009 at 6:27 am
Irisheye says
Piers…I admire you for your sympathetic feelings toward Susan Boyle…and your invitation to her for dinner. HOWEVER….I do not admire your back pedaling re: her chances towards her winning BGT. I view your latest responses to her performance as a political stand to keep your job! She is truly gifted and touches the heart and soul of humanity. I am totally supportive of her and what she represents to all of us out here in “the technological universe.” Please do no destroy our dreams or hers by trying to protect your job!!! She is in a CLASS BY HERSELF…nd you know it or you wouldn’t have invited her to dinner.
Irene in USA
April 28, 2009 at 6:35 am
Irisheye says
Piers…I admire your support of Susan Boyle. However, I see you as back-pedaling by not giving your full support to her in the BGT.
She is an inspiration to our entire planet…check out her hits on YouTube.
I know that you value what she represents to our entire planet or you would not have invited her to dinner in London. Please honor her and us and support her unconditionally in her journey to her dream. Your job and her future are on the line. Remember money isn’t everything!!! We are depending on you to be the REAL human in advancing this story and dream.
Blessings to you and Susan,
Irene in WA, USA
April 28, 2009 at 8:26 am
Canadagirl says
Piers,
Are you engaged to Celia? If this is truly so, as I read in an “interview” with comments by you
then why are you going on a date with Susan? I truly think you and Susan would be wonderful together, but please, don’t play with her heart.
Wishing all the best for Susan (and you).
Please let us know the outcome.
Canadagirl
April 28, 2009 at 8:59 am
simon c says
Yep u go Piers… honestly as always.. whens ur chat show/ interviews coming back on tv
April 28, 2009 at 1:32 pm
Barbara says
I too am wondering Canadagirl right here in Canada - toronto to be exact. I read that and got upset because he should not have invited her out to dinner if he is engage at all.
I too thought they would be good together he is more outspoken she is shy the ying to the yang. God does work in mysterious way wonders to perform I am praying for another miracle for Susan.
Here is hoping it will happen as the man upstairs intended it to be. She does have a terrife sense of humor I do believe and would keep him laughing. She is also very hot, and as Simon said a little tiger waiting to pounce.
April 28, 2009 at 2:21 pm
Ammie says
I just read that Susan’s family & friends are pushing her to get out of the BGT contract. She has become their goose who lays the golden egg.
It is quite sad. Everyone wants a piece of this woman. They better be careful, though. We like Susan for who she is, not who they force her to be. I, for one, will not purchase her CD to make her greedy brothers rich.
April 28, 2009 at 7:16 pm
Carol says
Piers, what a developed, sensitive human being you are!
This woman displayed as much grace and style in that semi-winning segment as she did vocal talent. Susan needs no improvement. Her demeanor, coupled with the professionalism of her delivery–especially in the face of the obvious skepticism overall of the panel and audience–is exactly what made her an instant star. ‘Improvement’ is not necessary.
Changing any part of this package–including her charming, earnest face–would be taking the apples out of the apple pie. The pictures I’ve seen of this so-called makeover have already removed some of that softness, and clean honesty.
April 28, 2009 at 11:34 pm
Marianne says
Dear Piers,
Thank you for supporting Susan Boyle. She is an angel. Her voice is as good as any professionals I have heard anywhere. Please get her to the States. We can’t wait to hear a concert and buy her CD’s. The United States wants Susan Boyle. !!!
April 28, 2009 at 11:49 pm
margaret says
Dear Piers, What a romantic name. So happy that you are taking Susan to dinner in London, she will have that date forever in her memory and you will give her the first kiss on the lips, yes? Watch you on America Got Talent, also check on the BGT since I am a british citizen living in US. Susan has got good taste she chose you over Simon. Have a great evening with Susan I think you will find quite a tiger and personality hiding in her,take good care of Susan. Love yours two books Insider and Dont you know who I am. Great stuff. Regards Margaret, usa formerly from Cheltenham
April 29, 2009 at 12:24 am
bluewren says
With all due respect I think not buying her CD to spite her family getting some benefit is a bit defeating My take on Susan would be her happiness is in being able to benefit her family.
In anycase I have complete confidence now Piers having learned more about you that you will see that Susan is well looked after as will Simon.Right?In anycase you are more than capable of playing the knight errant if you so choose.So I hope you do.Best wishes.
April 29, 2009 at 2:27 am
suzy says
Susan Boyle…What a gift she is to those of us who love her. Amazing woman with an amazing voice. My biggest fear is that all the backlash will kill her dreams before they’re born…then of course there is greed, envy and all the other deadly sins…
April 29, 2009 at 3:05 am
Del & Leslie McMillan says
Piers, thank you for graciously standing up for our beloved Susan. She needs a trustworthy messenger with her best interests in mind, and you have valuable experience in both journalism and show business. How good to dedicate this to noble purposes. Like others who posted, and millions who didn’t yet, we feel very protective of Susan and are praying for only good things for her. It is understandable that you and Simon have to praise the talents of other contestants, too, just to be fair to all and to give BGT a greater audience. But the only reason they are getting any attention outside of the UK is that they are riding Susan’s tidal wave, which seems to be beyond the natural. God will bless you as you bless her, Piers.
With blessings and prayers,
Del & Leslie
Brooklyn, New York, USA
April 29, 2009 at 6:01 am
iamjit says
I love Susan. I love her not only her fantastic voice but also the way she does…honest,sincere and the most lovely thing is she has a very good sense of humor and she is the very positive thinking lady.
Love you Susan.
Lots of love from Thailand.
April 29, 2009 at 12:59 pm
Julie says
BGT has brought laughter, tears and hope to so many of us here in the USA, in my State of Oregon and in my own life. Your blog here Piers, also brings me to my knees in laughter. In a time of great hardship, the comfort, inspiration, hope, joy and laughs brought into our homes through just youtube and show clips, is astonishing. After the age of 40 (I am 41), something apparently happens to a woman who is unmarried. She is a spinster, the older woman, etc…….and to see Ms. Boyle walk out and say “and that’s just one side of me” in reference to her age, made me laugh with delightand I was very proud of her. When her mouth opened and out came the voice of an angel I cried. I watched the faces of the judges over and over, seeing how she touched their hearts and filled them with joy. When she popped overtones, I cried more. Watching how touched Simon was, I cried more. Amazing.
Sometimes, the sky opens and the light shines through people like Susan Boyle, Julian Smith, Flawless and many others including Simon Cowell. What a beautiful heart and gift he has which is a side not shown on Idol.
I saw the impact of Susan Boyle on my patients at the hospital I work at. Glimmer and hope on faces that I had not seen for a while. Cheers and smiles. Neighbors gathered discussing Susan and Flawless. It is really quite amazing. Even my step has gotten lighter and although I haven’t performed vocally in years, I find myself singing as I go through my day.
April 29, 2009 at 1:26 pm
suzy says
Susan Boyle…stunning singer on BGT and her rendition on YouTube of Cry Me A River from 1999 is right up there with Billie Holiday….WOW…
April 29, 2009 at 2:48 pm
Ammie says
Hi Piers,
Can people from outside the UK vote for Susan Boyle? I really want to thank her for all of the joy she has given me these past couple of weeks.
April 29, 2009 at 4:19 pm
Friederike says
Hallo to you, Piers!
The first I have say is: Congratulations to your openminded and offensive blogging. You’re good as judge in “Britain’s got Talent” - really, but for me a mediamaniac themselves in Germany your articles spend much more obsession than your judgement on the show. I’m the writing type aswell. -
I had the chance to her Paul Potts singing when he was in Hamburg on stage. He was great. Since that I pear some interest for the British kind of talent shows. - And sorry, for Germany! The British variety is better. I say that though I love my country as much as it seems to be loved. Love shoudn’t blind objective views, you see.
The cause why you in UK work it much better out is, first there is no prejudging and preselection before the business runs. - Everybody can really do it, when they feel talented enough for it and has grit in the bones to do it.
In the German Shows like DSDS or German Supertalent there is a lot of preselection and prejudgement before and so you nearly always those model types well styled but talent is in summary not very big and the people appearing there on stage are forgotten very soon. What I miss here in my homecountry is the natural talent in the people and ofcourse there are a lot, but they got no chance with there normal figures and normal faces. They are not telegenetic enough for the television-companies.
In fact you and your co-acting team at BGT do a quite well job. Go on through! Wishing a lot of success for the next and former future.
With best regards
Friederike
April 30, 2009 at 3:43 am
bluewren says
As the days pass and you keep mentioning talent to come Susan seems to be fading in to the background with you here I just hope that is not a keep interest in BGT going strategy via Simon?After all he wouldn’t want them to just pack up their bags and all go home.
I rather wish Susan would leave now and take advantage of the publicity herself.
But think it is in her best interests to keep her good ralationships with BGT intact.After all Simon Cowell is powerful in the music industry I just hope she can keep up the momentum and she gets a really good deal.
April 30, 2009 at 4:29 am
bluewren says
Just had to come back here Piers I just heard Susan singing “Cry me a River” no worries she is never going to be upstaged or overlooked ever again.Apart from all of us millions I am convinced someone up there loves her & we are all watching.
So you are under tough scrutiny but I think that you like Susan are made of good stuff Piers.Each in your own way. Not in a conventionally romantic way perhaps but it is definitely kismet.
April 30, 2009 at 10:38 am
PATRICIA CHESTER.U.K says
I THINK SUSAN BOYLE HAS AMAZING TALENT A GOD GIVEN VOICE AND HAS CAPTURED ALL OUR HEARTS.IT IS A GREAT LESSON FROM WHICH WE ALL CAN LEARN HOW WE ALL JUDGE PEOPLE JUST BY ONE SUPERFICIAL LOOK NEVER CARING TO SEE THE BEAUTY WITHIN.SUSAN BOYLE IS A SHINING LIGHT SHE HAS RAISED US ALL UP AND GIVEN SO MUCH HOPE TO SO MAN ON MANY LEVELS AND TOUCHED SO MANY HEARTS.I WISH HER
THE VERY BEST.
April 30, 2009 at 10:42 am
PATRICIA CHESTER.U.K says
I THINK SUSAN BOYLE HAS AMAZING TALENT A GOD GIVEN VOICE AND HAS CAPTURED ALL OUR HEARTS.IT IS A GREAT LESSON FROM WHICH WE ALL CAN LEARN HOW WE ALL JUDGE PEOPLE JUST BY ONE SUPERFICIAL LOOK NEVER CARING TO SEE THE BEAUTY WITHIN.SUSAN BOYLE IS A SHINING LIGHT. SHE HAS RAISED US ALL UP AND GIVEN SO MUCH HOPE TO SO MANy ON MANY LEVELS AND TOUCHED SO MANY HEARTS.I WISH HER
THE VERY BEST.
April 30, 2009 at 11:54 am
missteek says
I never watch talent contests, I totally hate them.
I came across the Susan Boyle U tube clip, through watching the BBC news. I was mesmerised. (PS thats how I found this blog & daily RANTS)
I thought Flawless was fantastic, and things had improved in the league of talent contests. So I watched the week Holly appeared.
”I could have dounced all night” …….. TBH that was it for me, I switched off. This is everything I hate about talent competitions the mix bag of monkeys.
So whilst I’ll watch with interest the future of Susan Boyle, Flawless and Diversity - Saturday night for me, will not be Britains Got Talent.
But I enjoy a good RANT and moan site
… so I’ll keep you busy here.
April 30, 2009 at 3:03 pm
Lykke says
Am I the only one, who believe, that Susan Boyles statement, that she “had never been kissed” really meant, that she never had a sexual relationship?
I love her for her beautiful singing/voice, but even more for her lovely personality - shown before, during and after her performance in BGT.
April 30, 2009 at 4:22 pm
Paulette Reed says
Dear Piers,
Just a thought
Why not change the American show, to the winner hers an collage paid for and get to sing at the White House and a CD, Take away the $Million dollars to get the Greed out of it and up the age.
As the BGT, is much better done.
USA
April 30, 2009 at 8:04 pm
sweetpolly says
We Americans DO love to see the underdog prevail…Go Susan! <3
May 1, 2009 at 1:39 am
bluewren says
Sorry BGT those two will not do it you will have to come up with something better than those two.
May 1, 2009 at 2:39 am
Marianne says
Dear Piers,
YouTube has just produced another video of Susan Boyle - The Way We Were - Video From 1984 (From The Daily Record) She must have been in early twenties. Susan was so beautiful then as she still is. I cannot believe she hasn’t been discovered until now. It makes one wonder why not then. Thank God it isn’t too late for her and her fans. I wish Susan the best. Have a great date with her Piers. She and you are special.
May 1, 2009 at 3:13 am
Renee deWolf-Gibbons says
Piers,
Hollie and Shaheen are most likely flash-in-the-pan wunderkinds, who hopefully won’t develop laryngeal damage moron along the way who is trying to push them too hard, too fast. It’s ridiculous to even suggest that they are any “competition” for Susan! I’m a professional classically-trained singer and former voice professor, and I am telling you: Susan Boyle is the real thing. It makes zero difference if she wins the “talent (I use the term loosely) contest” or not. WE LOVE HER IN AMERICA AND WANT HER TO SING HER HEART OUT HERE. WE’LL BUY HER CD’s, WATCH HER ENDLESSLY ON TALK SHOWS, WATCH HER IN CONCERT AND IN SHOWS. She’s already MADE IT here. I’ve never even heard of “Robbie Williams” or “Jonathan Ross.” P.S. Most of us didn’t know who Elaine Paige was either! P.P.S I think the British media is very disrespectful and seems to enjoy holding down their own.
May 1, 2009 at 6:18 am
Billie O'Toole says
Piers, do you really think that anyone is going to buy a CD sung by a 10 year old girl or an 11 year old boy? The answer is NO, NO, NO.
Would we buy one by Susan Boyle? The answer is YES, YES, YES.
May 1, 2009 at 7:32 am
RJ Anderson says
Piers,
Your sneer at the beginning of Susan’s performance…well, you made up for it with your beautiful remarks.
Susan has won our hearts. No matter the outcome of BGT, I am grateful for her willingness to shine for the rest of the world.
I loved your comment about the tombstone. It may come to be true, but nonetheless you will be remembered. Thanks for your humor.
May 1, 2009 at 2:31 pm
Missteek says
reply to:
Renee deWolf-Gibbons
Thank you, it was very interesting to read a post from someone who could analyse Susan’s Voice, not that it needs analyses, I know what I like and l like it.
But with regard to her interview; not knowing the format of the programme, whether it’s ”mixed” live, i.e. between performer, audience, judges, presenters or mixed afterwards - Susan showed no pretence, I am what I am, may be a tad nervous may have chosen not to say ”never been kissed” …. but it’s a turn of phrase, as much as it was her honesty. Her’s was on reflection, quite a long interview compared with other contestants.
But Susan is a holistic performer, Voice, presentation, personality & appearance. Like any womany she’s gone off and had her hair done and facial - good on her. WE WOULD ALL HAVE DONE THIS.
May 1, 2009 at 4:01 pm
Ammie says
I just saw the video of Susan at age 22. She is so beautiful. I’m crying again.
May 1, 2009 at 9:02 pm
Marta says
It really isn’t who wins BGT as far as the rest of the world is concerned. BGT or not, Susan, is our star. We can’t wait for her CD and visit to the States. I realize from the press that Susan has a contract with BGT, but, for us that’s inconsequential as far as her success as a singer. She’s accomplished far being her wildest dream. I have her Cry Me and Killing Me songs on my mp3 player and car cd player. The vids of her in 1984 of The Way We and Don’t Know How to show how much singing has been her driving force. Yet, she gave it all up to care for others, even in a world that has always scorned her. This is her time to full achieve that dream and BGT catapulted her but it cannot hold her back. Win or lose BGT she’s our winner and we can’t wait to watch her bloom as a world star.
May 2, 2009 at 5:36 am
Teri says
Although I think I understand the sentiment you expressed re: the headlines when you pass on, there are worse things for which to be remembered. Ms. Boyle’s audition was a singularly sweet moment in time which brought joy to many people. You were part of it from the beginning and you were lucky enough to have been there in person when she sang. I envy you.
You are a dear for inviting Ms. Boyle out, I wish you at the least much fun and laughter.
May 2, 2009 at 5:37 am
Mary Jo says
I stand corrected by none other than Ms. Boyle herself, who wants to stay on the show. So be it. We Americans do not do well with delayed gratification, but if enough old tapes keep surfacing, like the one from 1984, it will at least keep us from tearing our hair out before the end of May.
May 2, 2009 at 10:08 am
Gabriel says
I’ve wtached the3 Boyle vid on youtube about 20 times and run every time I’m feeling a bit low. Yes, it was Susan’s voice, yes it was also Susan herself, such an anti-fashion/bimbo/botox icon, but it was more than that: it was bloody great television, One of my favourite bits of the video were the shots of Piers’ face - what a kind, sweet, face! - and the antics of the offstage guys (sorry, I’m in Australia and don’t have a TV) … as I say, it was fabulous television, with a whole lot of componenents which came together beautifully. I’ve seen a vid of American Idol, oh yukkk! So tacky. Go BGT!
May 2, 2009 at 3:24 pm
Carlo Chianese says
Dear Piers…
first of all please excuse my english, which is not so well (italian living in Switzerland).
I have no TV, but i often watch all the BGT Clips in youtube, and i love it. My compliment to this show!
And bigger compliment to all these talented people. BGT would be a reason to buy a TV again (LOL).
I would like to make a compliment to all of you. The show is amusing, interesting, thrilling, exciting, fascinating… my favourites of season 3 are of course Susan Boyle and Shaheen… Question: how comes that during Saheen’s performence, Simon could stop him, tell him he was doing copmpletely wrong and let him start over again with another song? Do all performers have a second song ready in case something like that happens? i did ot get that… seemd to me like it was already planned in advance? could u explain that? Please send my regards to your crew and mates… sincerely yours Carlo
May 2, 2009 at 4:31 pm
Janis says
Wow! It’s happened again, hasn’t it? I was a teenager for the Beatles “invasion” and happily here for Susan Boyle. I just wish we could get Britain’s Got Talent here. . . sigh. I spend a ridiculous amount of time on Utube ~ good thing I’m retired or it would definitely be a problem. Now here is your great blog and, well, I guess my family will just be ignored for the time being!
Just want to say “Good on you” and thanks very much.
Janis from California, USA
May 2, 2009 at 6:55 pm
Debbie L Battrick says
SUSAN BOYLE- A blessing from above
Song I dreamed a dream
Susan Boyle is a courageous woman
A blessing from above,
She looks like an Angel
And is filled with God’s love.
She has the talent and the gift
To make her dreams come true,
And the voice of a Angel
She wants to share with you.
Susan is quite young and single
God has made her that way,
She lives alone with her cat, Pebbles
And treasures him everyday.
So when you hear Susan sing
With her voice reaching the skies,
Just say a little prayer for her
Till tears fills your eyes.
Debbie L Battrick
April 25, 2009
May 2, 2009 at 9:51 pm
Paulette Reed says
Mr. Piers,
I watch tonight your new program, but still love Susan as #1 The guy does sing good has a sweet voice,, what in the world are you people putting in the water. BGT, Is so much better then what Simon has going in American;) as its so bad I dont watch it.;) Have you been out to dinner with Susan?;)
God Bless
May 3, 2009 at 2:28 am
Janez says
Ok, although Hollie, Shahen, Jamie Pugh and maybe someone else do have talent, we are missing something here. Susan didn’t shock the world so much with singing in technical sense but with the open heart. I don’t see her losing BGT unless she cracks down completely in semifinals due to being huge, biggest ever favourite not only in this competition, but she seems to be strong and it’s not just something on personal level. This strenght and grace have come out from her difficult life, and no doubt, from her faith. Being, or trying to be, spiritual person myself, I know very few people who have this faith alive within. It is a living thing inside, one that goes beyond description. No, Susan can’t lose anymore, no matter what other competitors do. It would take whistling dragons on flying carpets to challenge Susan now and she would still win. But she has already won, she has opened our hearts and has become part of ourselves.
May 3, 2009 at 5:15 am
Patricia says
I just love Susan. I love hearing her speak,she is adorable and funny , and just plain cute !
May 3, 2009 at 5:38 am
Patricia says
I just wanted to add with regard to your comments on can anyone beat Susan Boyle , regardless of what happens on the show ,Susan’s already won. She has a huge audience waiting to buy her first CD and I’m won of them. The results of the contest doesn’t
matter to me, I’m already a fan,one of many.
May 3, 2009 at 3:31 pm
Del & Leslie McMillan says
Piers, we’re still praying for you and your dinner with Susan, that it will be (already has been?) a true blessing for both of you. Jesus is involved here, and He has a plan that includes surrender and sanctification. Allow Him to fulfill His purpose for you, and it will be even more stunning than Susan’s glorious singing!
Blessings,
Del & Leslie
Brooklyn, New York
May 3, 2009 at 5:50 pm
merryizmae says
Thank you Susan!! I have your “cry me a river” and your BGT audtion on my Ipod and when I need a smile or encouragement I listen and all is well again. Who the heck is Elaine Paige? Don’t change you are perfect just as you are. Can’t wait until you are performing in Northern Ohio (Cleveland). Be asured I will be in the front row.
MaryAnn Leone
May 3, 2009 at 6:36 pm
Teresa says
Hi,
In my opinion, there is lots of fuss about youngsters. Well, yes, they are very good, but they can win the next time…..
Anyway, I want to say, Susan´s performance was outstanding and great, and everyone of you put ( some heart )something into it. Besides, Piers looks such a nice Englishman, but Simon more like a tiger, as I look at it from outside,- lol.
Love from Sweden.
May 3, 2009 at 6:44 pm
Teresa says
Which is of course very sweet and exciting as it was meant to be said to Susan…..
May 3, 2009 at 6:59 pm
Marianne says
Dear Piers,
Jamie Pugh was very good but I still favor Susan Boyle. I did not like the presentation part of the judges. It looked very ’staged” for YouTube. In fact I think I have seen Jamie somewhere before but can’t place it right now. Same performance. Wonder where I saw it ????
May 3, 2009 at 7:16 pm
Delia says
Mr. Morgan,
I have seen Jamie Pugh’s performance on Britain’s Got Talent 5 times. Each time I could not keep the tears from falling. If anyone depicts the theme of your show it is him. I saw Susan Boyle’s video and never cried. I felt excited when she surprised everyone with her talent. But Jamie Pugh’s performance really touched my heart.
I live in Texas so I cannot see your show. I watch the videos on You Tube Sundays. I only wish that I could vote so that I could show support for Jamie Pugh.
My family really loves Ant and Dec. They are half of the reason we watch your videos! If only they would come to America and do our show. They are very respectful of the applicants and do not talk down to them, no matter if they may not be talented.
Of all three judges, I watch you closely. Your face lets us know how you feel before you voice your opinion. And even when you buzzed the little girl who cried, we could see that you didn’t really want to hurt her feelings.
I’m glad you’re part of America’s Got Talent. But personally, I think you need two new judges. Sharon’s okay, but David doesn’t seem to be all that interested in finding real talent.
Good luck in helping to choose the finalists!
Delia and her family
May 3, 2009 at 8:55 pm
JoAnn Muir says
My last name is Muir and my Chesapeake Bay Retriever (hunting dog) is Einstein. I want to know, I am in Minnesota USA How can I vote for Susan Boyle? I can’t wait to buy her recordings. She was very pretty as a young girl, too. I was raised Irish Catholic, so I TOTALLY understand why she never hooked up. She is definitely pretty enough. She should do a duet with Barbra S. and Emilou Harris, etc. She will. WE LOVE YOU SUSAN. GO GIRL. Can’t get enough of your boring, un-star like life.
May 3, 2009 at 10:11 pm
Kari Buer says
It’s lovely to see all the amasing talents that is finding their way in to our homes across the globe. Susan Boyle and Jamie Pugh are two fantastic singers. I’m looking forward to more from these two. I would also like to see more of Piers’ the resisstance. Good luck from Norway.
May 3, 2009 at 11:28 pm
bluewren says
Well if Susan goes through with it then I want to see her win that too. Is it possible to get TV. Chanels in other countries to run Britan’s got Talent ? Could that give us all the right to vote?
Also I hope Catherine Zeta Jones does not get to play her in the movie they want to make of her life.
Surely there is a Scottish actress or an English one for that matter who could do the job? There really isn’t much talent left in Hollywood,with enough soul to play her I think.
You might even find another unkown like herself?Well we can always dream.>:-).
May 5, 2009 at 1:10 am
jae says
Just a “Piers! You are the best! You make the shows BGT and AGT!!!! Just that simple! I can hardly wait for your comments. Although I noticed when Terry Fator was on AGT from the very gitgo, you NEVER had a negative thing to say about him! You are pure class.
\
May 6, 2009 at 3:05 am
Lynne Lysiak says
RE:”The Boyle phenomenon has got so insane, I’ve got a horrible feeling that when I die, the headlines are now going to read: ‘JUDGE IN SUSAN BOYLE VIDEO DIES.’” Nonsense. Watching your reaction to her performance on the footage; the sheer, unadulterated appreciation of her performance; the joy of one human’s interaction with another’s talent, will forever stand as a tribute to your humanity. At the end of the day, what more could one ask to be remembered for.
May 7, 2009 at 12:34 am
Ladybrucknel says
Great blog Piers,you are a person with integrity hope you continue to be nice to Susan Boyle especially when it comes to her contract with Simon.
Don’t worry about Susan falling in love with you Piers she has too much common sense (unlike some of your posters here)and knows her measure and yours by now.Definetly she likes you a lot but that is why she is just playing along with it.
But those terrible pictures of her that creeps are plastering all over the web.Can someone do something about them?
Hope this all makes her happier in the end.If she does not win and she has to go back to her everyday life she will at least be better off financially.
I can see her shrugging her shoulders and just getting on with life.Saying “well I gave it my best shot.That’s that.
May 10, 2009 at 6:42 am
Harriet Martin says
Piers, you seem to be such a gentleman and just an especially nice person. Could you please state the rules regarding voting on BGT’s show? May other countries vote and, if so, exactly how does a person do so? May a person vote via the internet -or- what is the phone # to call or whatever the procedure? I’m certain there are many people who wish to know the answer to this subject.
May 12, 2009 at 5:12 pm
Bob Richards says
So Piers how do you feel about that designation that a poster here has stated….that when you die the way that people will reference you will be you were one of the judges on the Susan Boyle video…betya never thought that would be your legacy right ? : )
May 12, 2009 at 10:12 pm
bluewren says
Cannot stay away and am driving friends crazy with my emails about Susan Boyle.There are actually people who did not see it??? Ha!
I Was really pleased to see on utube a post that came right out and said it “It was like a religious experience.” so it was.
If Simon Cowell does not move to get those CD’s or albums out ASAP he might very well miss the wave.Can he get BGT onto American TV? That could be spectacular for Susan.
LOL.Piers The previous poster Doesn’t know it was you yourself who said that?;-D!
May 24, 2009 at 4:58 am
Debbie L Battrick says
Susan Boyle is a courageous woman
A blessing from above,
She looks like an Angel
And is filled with God’s love.
She has the talent and the gift
To make her dreams come true,
And the voice of a Angel
She wants to share with you.
Susan is quite young and single
God has made her that way,
She lives alone with her cat, Pebbles
And treasures her everyday.
So when you hear Susan sing
With her voice reaching the skies,
Just say a little prayer for her
Till tears fill your eyes. ©
May 25, 2009 at 6:22 am
Eleanor McLaughlin says
I agree with all the fuss over Suan Boyle. I am wondering when will she complete her CD. She is an inspiration to people with her beautiful voice and her love of singing. I felt so sad to hear how her mother wanted her to be a professional singer and is not around to see this fame she is receiving. She truly was a surprise and I can’t remember how I watched her the first time, but I am hooked on her lovely voice. Your fellow judges have been so kind to her to this deserving woman and I like everyone feel she deserves the fame and hopefully she will win and sing for the Royal Family and have a dinner date with a very nice man.
May 31, 2009 at 12:38 am
helen says
Dear Piers,
Thanks so much for recognizing the fantastic talent that Susan has. I give her all the credit in the world for taking a chance on BGT. I love her voice, she sings like an angel. Take good care of her and help her to realise she is a very special Scottish lassie.
Helen (USA)
PS: Born and brought up in Scotland :-).
May 31, 2009 at 10:40 am
Frances says
I just finished watching Susan Boyle on the Final show. She was incredible! I wished she would have won. I would not want to be in her shoes right now and it seems as though, from watching and reading about her, journalists, news crews whomever it may be, want to find mistakes in her, dig for faults, wrong doings and why? I could not handle being a big overnight sensation and Susan is going through a lot right now. Give her a break! If she decides to record an album/CD, I will be the first in my state to buy one. She has a very beatuiful voice!
FranWV
June 2, 2009 at 5:21 pm
PRomano says
I hope you encourage Ms. Boyle to record an album. Her voice is magnificient and refreshing, sharing it with us is a pleasure to enjoy.
I hope you guide her while ruthless individuals try to pull her down. She needs the assistance to face the bulldogs of the press. Shameful to try to destroy a humble, caring, gererous and innocent individual.
June 3, 2009 at 3:47 am
Veronica says
Hello Piers, you probably may not publish this and thats ok, but i must say this to get it off my chest.For the first time in my life i am ashamed of my Englishness. Flashback happened, as i suddenly remembered at the end this fiasco, a Scottish top runner for the win was about to enter the final and deserved to win as everyone expected.Then i was informed by present english company, that would not happen, best talent or not. as most english phone voters ring in the likely one to be in Semi Finals, then ring on the finals night for an English contestant best or not! Susan Boyle had her dream shattered not by failing ro win, but by dishonest Dealings and conscienless wheelers and dealers. She opened her lovely heart, and despite the gracious way she dealt, was used and abused. She was treat so badly an age and looks, attacked even before she sang a note. If she had wanted she could have stormed offstage and sued on such grounds, but no, instead sh said “I know Nothing” twice to save embarrasment to BGT and its judges. Then comes the press,after she had opened her heart and home on demand, amd gave her all to their demands.No one hounded the winner, or 3rd runner up. IT says a lot right their!!! when Susan came into Court for the last lolol judgeing, she did an amazingly humble and true performanc, and went through the slings ans arrows narrowly disguised to all but her and one or two others, with enormous quiet dignity and said not a word to defend herself. but thanked the judges, and all who supported her in this battle. Tnen i had another flashback and ” The words” ” I am among friends am i not” were her quiet utterance. they said a million words, because i heard long ago that if a Scottish contestant can ever leave the “am i not” off the that saying, than justice has indeed been done,!!! She was touted, flattered, abused, and if someone had cut the ear off one of the non friends, she would i know have picked that ear up and stuck it back on the attacker. No wonder she felt homesick and sick at heart. She has too much didnity to carry that out and payed for that all the way.As for her comback at the press hounds and nerdo-wells, i truly believe that the Pope and Queen dont say oh deary me when they for instance bang a toe on the end of the bed, its a ***** while their eyes water. That is a far cry from the plate Susan Boyle was dished up for her pain till she made an utterance. I think i will apply for Scottish residency permit. p.s that woman who danced like the one carrying the cup of abominations(innocent as she was)was also a victim to be oggled. She i take it was not buzzed out, for all that she would never be on the Royal Commaned Performance, Was her act, publicly done , children probaly watching a lot more acceptable than Susans Gut cry for mercy????. i will never watch such a fiasco again. it hurt so much i feel like turning the atmospher blue with the pain of it all. God Bless Susan Boyle and He Will. God Help Us All.
June 3, 2009 at 3:59 am
"boxerpaws" Sarver says
reporters tracked her (Susan)down,hounded her, chased her all over the place,did everything they could do to come up with a story to sell their rags then THEY complained she was over-hyped.I’ll guarantee that’s what the whole scuffle was about and they then decided to fix her.
I don’t know why people eat this stuff either.Are they that gullible? It’s a shame what’s happened to Susan.Now they(media and her critics)act like she’s to blame because she sought fame.I don’t think she had any idea how all of this was going to go.She wasn’t even sure she could pass the audition let alone what’s transpired since.
Yeah,Susan can be a little silly-and maybe some of her antics didn’t go well-but i’ve seen way worse over the years from people who have done a lot worse things and lived incredibly hedonistic lives.I hope she gets well and isn’t taken advantage of.
I just don’t trust people who are celebrities much.They can be very narcissistic and self serving. I don’t like to see anyone get used.
June 4, 2009 at 1:58 pm
elizabeth says
i hope susan is getting well i bought a ticket for the show in glasgow,but i dont think susan will be there,if i had known even my friends we wouldnt have bought a ticket for the show,hopefully we can see her very soon,we were all upset about her taking ill what a shame, susan is wonderfull take care get well soon
love eliz glasgow
June 5, 2009 at 1:03 am
eriskay says
Piers, you are correct, as usual. Susan may not have won first place in BGT but that wasn’t her goal. She wanted to be given the chance to perform,with the end goal being a career in singing. She has achieved that, thanks to BGT. I don’t think I’ve ever seen Simon smile like that before, in episode one. The three of you have been her champions and as far as the media goes………Prrrrttttt!!
I hate to say it, but I’ve never watched America’s Got Talent. I will from now on. Hope it’s as good as BGT. That is some great show and what Talent!!
slainte
June 6, 2009 at 10:49 pm
Marie says
Piers, I have seen you once on tv but after watching Susan’s clip on Youtube numerous times, I just love her singing. Then I watched you gave favorable inteviews about Susan and it really pleased me. She almost feel like a sister to me. If you read my comment, I just want to tell you that you are a good human being…you have class and character.
Even though, I don’t agree with your assessment on President Bush, I will just let that slide. Please be good to Susan. Hey, if the date does not go through as plan, count me in. I can’t sing but I can dance….he he.
June 8, 2009 at 2:36 am
Olga Savvidis says
My above sentiment extends to the wry Mr. Simon Cowall. I think both of you “gentlemen” need to grow up. I am certain that privilege and money undermines certain people’s humanity and decency…
July 15, 2009 at 1:25 am
bluewren says
I don’t know what is going on with Susan Boyle right now Piers and you yourself have become exceedingly quiet on the subject. ( not a good sign)
!
However I have several personal videos on my website recording the Susan Boyle Saga and I have to admit on review that you were exceptional in supporting her and I have to congratulate you sincerely. Looks like I have converted myself.LOL.
Lets have an appearance by Susan soon?
July 15, 2009 at 7:07 am
bluewren says
When are we going to get to see Susan Boyle again Piers? You have become very quiet on the subject.
You did such an excellent job defending and her in the past.What is actually happening with Susan now? So many people would like to know we are getting toey waiting and waiting.What’s up?
July 18, 2009 at 5:41 am
bluewren says
Oh boy! What can I say just saw the snippet interview of what’s to come on the 22nd.Susan is ok. You could almost feel the sigh of relief from her fansite.Some confessed to be dancing for joy.
As for me I feel as if I’ve just done a round with Mike Tyson I have been fighing so hard on Utube and with videos.And anyone who dared say a stupid ignorant bad word against her.I’ll probably get thrown off.:-(.LOL.
Piers you must have experienced it in spades.You were in the front line,and you did such a good job.Congratulations.If Susan did have a “crush “on you I can now really understand why.
Ok. I am so relieved and happy just give us more of Susan please.Take good care of her.